
So Hanif Kureishi has self-catalogued himself as the emblematic arrogant writer and frustrated human being that the rest of the world loves to hate and that gives other serious creative writers a bad reputation.
I am so outraged by what he said last May 27 during the Hay Festival in London, that I don't even know how to write this post. I searched around the Internet to find some sort of explicative counterpart to his exaggerated pronouncement, hopeful to come across something to redeem him. But all I found was more proof of how cruel and foul-mouthed he has been in his writing career, even to his own family. Since then, many people have actually dared to label his novels, especially The Buddha of Suberbia as pretentious manifestos.
I do not want to be judgmental (*pause for thought*) and place myself on the side of sensationalist observers who immediately catalog public figures as being amoral, evil or careless. To a certain extent, I have a feeling that most writers adopt this controversial persona, just to create the drama that fires up their writing (yes, I am thinking of Salman Rushdie). I don't consider this eccentric or cool, it's something closer to a profound sadness of the soul.
Nevertheless, let's analyze Kureishi's words for what they really want to say.
That creative writing courses are "the new mental hospitals", I believe this is to some extent true. It's the same as saying that everyone that studies psychology has some mental issues that they need to resolve. Writing by definition has always been a means to externalize inner demons that other non-writer human beings decide to externalize in a different manner. So yes, all creative writers must be a bit loony, solitary, inadecuate and unhappy. For anyone that dares to think a little beyond Kureishi's word, it wouldn't be so hard to come tot he same conclusion.
What I found a little more than shocking was the comparison between students of creative writing and the killers in the different US shootings that have happened in recent years. "One of the things you notice is that when you switch on the television and a student has gone mad with a machine gun on a campus in America, it's always a writing student". I tried to confirm this fact, but was unable to confirm that all the students were in fact writing students. However, even though I still hope Kureishi was using his writing persona again whilst saying this, this argument can be easily dismembered with a different logic.
These young assassins had other things in common besides writing: they all suffered from stress and mental disorders. One of the ways to externalize these feelings of anger and frustration, especially for young students, is by writing about them on blogs, diaries, etc. It's really no surprise that these kids wrote. Most teenager sdab at writing a few verses even in their youth. That doesn't mean they will become psycho-killers.
About the 71% mark he always gives his students at Kingston University in Stockwell London, well, I just feel sorry for them. And I hope he doesn't get into trouble for it. It's quite despicable to adopt such a lenient and lazy attitude in front of passionate students, who why the hell not, believe that they can make it as writers (especially if you are telling them that they can!).
Kureishi's attitude in general was demeening during his intervention at the Hay. I just wish I were closer to the action so I could hear what's cooking in its surroundings.
I am so outraged by what he said last May 27 during the Hay Festival in London, that I don't even know how to write this post. I searched around the Internet to find some sort of explicative counterpart to his exaggerated pronouncement, hopeful to come across something to redeem him. But all I found was more proof of how cruel and foul-mouthed he has been in his writing career, even to his own family. Since then, many people have actually dared to label his novels, especially The Buddha of Suberbia as pretentious manifestos.
I do not want to be judgmental (*pause for thought*) and place myself on the side of sensationalist observers who immediately catalog public figures as being amoral, evil or careless. To a certain extent, I have a feeling that most writers adopt this controversial persona, just to create the drama that fires up their writing (yes, I am thinking of Salman Rushdie). I don't consider this eccentric or cool, it's something closer to a profound sadness of the soul.
Nevertheless, let's analyze Kureishi's words for what they really want to say.
That creative writing courses are "the new mental hospitals", I believe this is to some extent true. It's the same as saying that everyone that studies psychology has some mental issues that they need to resolve. Writing by definition has always been a means to externalize inner demons that other non-writer human beings decide to externalize in a different manner. So yes, all creative writers must be a bit loony, solitary, inadecuate and unhappy. For anyone that dares to think a little beyond Kureishi's word, it wouldn't be so hard to come tot he same conclusion.
What I found a little more than shocking was the comparison between students of creative writing and the killers in the different US shootings that have happened in recent years. "One of the things you notice is that when you switch on the television and a student has gone mad with a machine gun on a campus in America, it's always a writing student". I tried to confirm this fact, but was unable to confirm that all the students were in fact writing students. However, even though I still hope Kureishi was using his writing persona again whilst saying this, this argument can be easily dismembered with a different logic.
These young assassins had other things in common besides writing: they all suffered from stress and mental disorders. One of the ways to externalize these feelings of anger and frustration, especially for young students, is by writing about them on blogs, diaries, etc. It's really no surprise that these kids wrote. Most teenager sdab at writing a few verses even in their youth. That doesn't mean they will become psycho-killers.
About the 71% mark he always gives his students at Kingston University in Stockwell London, well, I just feel sorry for them. And I hope he doesn't get into trouble for it. It's quite despicable to adopt such a lenient and lazy attitude in front of passionate students, who why the hell not, believe that they can make it as writers (especially if you are telling them that they can!).
Kureishi's attitude in general was demeening during his intervention at the Hay. I just wish I were closer to the action so I could hear what's cooking in its surroundings.




